top of page
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Twitter Icon

Cricket’s dirty laundry had nowhere to go

The Nightwatchman
4 hours ago
5 min read
Current and former Australian cricketers Cameon Bancroft, David Warner, Usman Khawaja, Pat Cummins, Mitch Starc and Josh Hazlewood are at the centre of a storm eight years in the making. (Photo - Kyle Pollard)
Current and former Australian cricketers Cameon Bancroft, David Warner, Usman Khawaja, Pat Cummins, Mitch Starc and Josh Hazlewood are at the centre of a storm eight years in the making. (Photo - Kyle Pollard)


There is an old rule in Australian sport that what happens in the rooms stays in the rooms. It’s partly about loyalty and partly about self-protection. For generations it held because the people who broke it paid for it. You didn’t get picked again, you didn’t get the commentary job, and your mates stopped answering the phone. Sometimes, though, the rule protects the room at the expense of the few people standing outside it.

In less than a fortnight that rule has fallen apart. On 6 November an excerpt from Usman Khawaja’s autobiography claimed the whole 2018 touring party knew about the sandpaper, and that it had been used before Cape Town. Within days David Warner called the account accurate. Pat Cummins then gave a 68-minute press conference rejecting it as nonsense. Chadd Sayers said everyone in that side knew. Then on Wednesday night Cameron Bancroft, the man caught with the sandpaper, released a statement of about 4,000 words. In it he says the tampering began in the second Test at Port Elizabeth, continued almost every over until Cape Town, and was discussed openly on the field with the bowlers and the keeper.

The responses have followed a familiar pattern. Cummins’ manager says Bancroft’s statement raises nothing Cummins hasn’t already answered, and that his position hasn’t changed in eight years. Darren Lehmann, accused by Bancroft of knowing about the sandpaper, told ABC Radio he needs time to read the allegations and work through them. Cricket Australia says it expects there will be “many dimensions” to what happened. Plenty of people are calling all this ugly, and it is. A lot of them also say grown men who shared a dressing room should have sorted it out among themselves.

I’d argue the opposite. Dirty laundry gets aired in public when there was never anywhere private to wash it.

Start with what 2018 cost. Steve Smith lost the Australian captaincy at 28 and was banned for a year. Warner was banned for a year and told he would never lead his country again. Bancroft, 25 and seven Tests into his career, was banned for nine months. All three lost sponsors, their IPL contracts went or their county deals fell through, and they spent the next year being booed at grounds around the world. For eight years the three of them have been the public face of the worst moment in Australian cricket. Smith has carried it through every press conference, Warner through every sledge and every sandpaper waved from the stands, and Bancroft in near silence.

Now look at what Bancroft says about how that happened. He admits he didn’t give investigators a full and truthful account. He says he withheld when the sandpaper use began, how long it went on and who else knew, partly to protect Cricket Australia’s investigation and partly to avoid implicating the people around him. He also says that once he’d been caught, some in the team and staff urged him to lie, which is how a nervous 25-year-old ended up telling the world it was yellow tape. By his account, Smith wanted no part of the plan when it was raised and argued for coming clean once it was exposed, and Warner raised the idea in a room where others agreed. None of that makes any of them blameless, and none of them have claimed it does. What it does is change the shape of the story the public was told.

The investigation was built for exactly the story the public got. It ran inside a week, found three players responsible, called it an isolated incident and handed down bans that were heavier than anything the ICC imposed. When the then CEO was asked in 2018 whether CA would look at claims of sandpaper use at Port Elizabeth, his answer was “not at this stage.” The aim was obviously speed and containment. Give the public its villains, punish them, and move on before the sponsors and broadcasters lost patience. If the accounts now emerging are right, three men took the punishment for something far more people knew about, and the process was designed in a way that let that happen.

Bancroft also describes a team staff member objecting during a meeting at Port Elizabeth and walking out of the discussion. If that’s true, someone inside the tent raised it at the time and nothing changed. That is what it looks like when there’s nowhere to wash the laundry.

Then there is the price of speaking. In 2021 Bancroft hinted that the bowlers probably knew. Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon issued a joint denial, CA said it would look again, and the story went quiet. Bancroft hasn’t played a Test since 2019 despite years near the top of the Shield run lists. He now writes that he wondered whether his presence in an Australian dressing room would bring back questions others wanted left alone, and whether it was simply easier not to pick him. Nobody can prove that, and selectors will say otherwise. But the fact that he believes it shows how the old rule is enforced. You don’t need a formal penalty for talking when people already think the cost is their career.

So the story stayed with those who knew it until they decided keeping quiet cost more than speaking. Khawaja retired and wrote a book. Warner, who has had his name dragged through this for longer than anyone, backed him straight away. Bancroft says Cummins’ press conference left him feeling angry, betrayed and alone. None of them had anywhere the truth could be tested properly, so they used the only places available: a publisher and a newspaper.

On Wednesday morning, hours before Bancroft’s statement went public, Cricket Australia announced a confidential forum where people from the tour could give evidence privately to an independent chair who would report to the board. Its terms of reference still aren’t final. Bancroft says he will attend. But by that evening Alastair Cook was already making the obvious point that Bancroft had “opened his own forum.” A promise of a quiet room means very little to people who have already walked outside, and even less to the three who were never offered one in 2018.

None of this makes the public airing good. Careers and reputations are being argued over in headlines with no cross-examination, no right of reply and no finding of fact at the end. Bancroft’s account is detailed and has nothing obvious in it for him, but it is still one man’s memory of events eight years ago. Cummins and the others he names deny it, and they deserve a fair process too. But fairness has to cut both ways. If the people named now are entitled to a proper hearing, so were the three who were sent home from Johannesburg inside a week.

The answer to dirty laundry in the street is not to tell people to take it back inside and keep quiet. It is to build somewhere it can actually be cleaned. That would be a genuinely independent inquiry with real powers and a public outcome, one that doesn’t answer to the board whose reputation is on the line and doesn’t leave witnesses wondering what speaking will cost them. If it finds the burden of 2018 was shared, then the record should say so, and Smith, Warner and Bancroft should get the correction they’ve waited eight years for.


Until that exists, expect more books, more statements and more press conferences, all before the summer’s first Test in Perth. Every one will be a reminder that the game chose a quick answer over a true one, and that three players have been paying for that choice ever since.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2018 by dzl industries

  • Grey Facebook Icon
  • Grey Twitter Icon

Just a couple of blokes with their take on the day of cricket.

The nightwatchman is for those budding cricket analysts, commentators, writers and bloggers to have their opportunity to get their written pieces more audience. Many of us area amateur writers with our own careers and family life taking up most of our days, however, we have always found time to write about the pressing issues in cricket that matter most to us, after dark, well after play. This is why we are the nightwatchman. 

To contribute to the nightwatchman, please contact us.

bottom of page